Recognising revenue as a long contract progresses — and the estimate the whole method rests on.
Percentage of completion recognises revenue on a long-running contract in proportion to progress, rather than at delivery. Progress is commonly measured cost-to-cost: costs incurred divided by total estimated costs. Recognised revenue is that percentage of the contract value, with the difference from amounts billed appearing as over- or under-billing.
For a contract spanning several periods, recognising everything at completion makes the accounts useless in the meantime. Percentage of completion spreads revenue across the periods in which the work happens. The weakness is that it depends entirely on estimated total cost — a figure produced by the people whose performance it reflects.
The agreed revenue, including approved variations. Unapproved variations are a judgement and should be treated conservatively.
The critical input. Reviewed each period, by someone who can be challenged on it.
Cost-to-cost most commonly, though surveys of work performed or units delivered suit some contracts better.
Percentage complete applied to contract value, less revenue already recognised.
Recognised revenue compared with amounts invoiced gives the over- or under-billing to disclose.
A construction contract has a value of 5 crore and an expected cost of 4 crore. Three months in, cost incurred is 1.2 crore, so cost-to-cost gives 30 percent complete and revenue of 1.5 crore.
The difficulty is what that 1.2 crore consists of. If it includes 40 lakh of materials delivered to site but not yet installed, those materials represent expenditure rather than progress — the work they will become has not been done. Including them overstates completion and pulls revenue forward. Most standards require such costs to be excluded from the progress calculation for exactly this reason, and including them is one of the more common errors in practice.
Excluding uninstalled materials gives 80 lakh of progress cost, 20 percent complete and revenue of 1 crore. The 50 lakh difference is a real profit timing difference, and in an early period it can be the difference between a contract looking healthy and looking marginal. The general caution is that cost-to-cost is only as good as the definition of which costs measure progress.
| Term | What it means |
|---|---|
| Input method | Measuring progress by resources consumed, such as cost incurred against total expected cost. |
| Output method | Measuring progress by results delivered, such as units completed or milestones certified. |
| Over-billing | Billing ahead of recognised revenue, which is a liability. |
| Under-billing | Revenue recognised ahead of billing, which is a contract asset. |
| Onerous contract | One expected to make a loss, which must be recognised in full immediately. |
An estimate to complete left unchanged while costs overrun inflates recognised margin until the final period, when it collapses.
Revenue recognised on a variation the client has not approved may never be collected.
Materials delivered early can make cost-to-cost overstate progress. Consider excluding uninstalled materials.
The person estimating cost to complete is usually the person judged on margin. The estimate needs challenge.
| Metric | What it tells you | What distorts it |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage complete by method | Comparing input and output measures. Large divergence means one of them is wrong. | |
| Estimate at completion movement | Changing total cost estimates, which retrospectively change every prior period's percentage. | |
| Billing versus revenue position | Over- and under-billing by contract, which is the balance sheet consequence. | |
| Contracts in expected loss | Onerous contracts, which must be recognised in full as soon as they are identified. |
We build and support the systems this page describes. Start with a free working proof of concept — no cost, no commitment.